Which one is better and long lasting: eyeliner pencil or wet eyeliner brush dipped in eyeshadow?

i prefer bare minerals eyeliner shadows, they can be used wet or dry, and last super long.Which one is better and long lasting: eyeliner pencil or wet eyeliner brush dipped in eyeshadow?
M.A.C.Which one is better and long lasting: eyeliner pencil or wet eyeliner brush dipped in eyeshadow?
They're really about the same. But to make both last longer, I sweep on a layer of sheer or translucent powder. That way the eyeliner is protected from the skin's natural oils for a few hours longer.